Today is the day not to say the wrong thing.
Hey: for some reason they asked me to be on the panel at this, so if you live in Chicago and are interested in freelance writing, come by--it's free. Columbia College: it's the Columbia University of the Midwest!
Children's Bible Lessons Who am I?: Make a list of questions pertaining to Sunday School bible stories and have guests guess who the person is (example - I was swallowed by a whale = Jonah).
Birth of Jesus Story: Have your guest recount the Story of Baby Jesus' birth in their own unique style...
Worship Song Fill in the Blank: Start off a line of a popular children's worship song and have guests either write down or sing the rest of the song (example - this little light of mine, I'm gonna ______).
Building Blocks of Life: Get a large stack of baby blocks, and have guests take turns stacking them. Each time a guest stacks a block, have them tell what they believe is an important building block of life (ie : having faith or good sense of humor). If a guest fails to name something, they're out. The winner is the last person to stack a block BEFORE the stack falls (not the guest who topples the stack).
Go Tell it on the Mountain: This mountain being the center or front of the room. Have each guest stand up and tell something good about themselves, or about the parents-to-be.